I was disappointed with the 3 Magic Reeds I just received. Although you can make a recognizable sound, they are all quite unstable to even use as practice reeds. I 'may' be able to fix them up by rebalancing them since the tip is generous. I wonder if these reeds are actually tested...not sure how they would pass considering the price. However, compared to the EB Pro reeds I also ordered, they are much better.

Can the reed be played on, yes. Will it sound good, if you’re good enough. For a reed bought online they're good but still have the attributes of most reeds that are bought online.

Good rich sound on all registers. Takes a week to break in.

Loose wrapping, leaked instead of playing, no matter how much I soaked them.

I have been using this kind of reed for almost 2 years straight now and have never had any issues with any that I have purchased. This reed allows for beautiful tone quality throughout. I have noticed they last much longer than others that I have tried before. The magic reed-no pun intended, is magic! I would recommend this to anyone, even beginners, as the reed comes in medium and hard. I will always be repurchasing this reed!

I’ve been playing for three years and finally taking the step up to “real” medium reeds. (I’ve been playing commercial mediums from Amazon until now.) Even though the Magic was immediately harder to play, still, the first thing I noticed was how warm and full the sound is. The response was a little difficult (didn’t speak very well), and required a lot of embouchure adjustment in the 3rd octave. I’ve done some minor adjustments, like scraping the tip and the windows, and after a couple of weeks, it speaks easily and still plays beautifully. I’m definitely going to be trying more of them.

I've played on many of these reeds over the past year, and on the whole, they are very good reeds. Every once in a while I'll get a dud, something that's extremely nasal and thin....and that sucks, but I suppose this happens to the best of makers!